New + Exciting

New pieces across all categories! Find the newest in diamond, custom, gemstone, turquoise + special occasion.



    never out of style, never big enough


    pierced diamonds for a delicate look


    because jewelry is meant to stand out from the crowd


Meet Katelynne

Katelynne, whose nickname as a child was "Sugar Plum", is the founder and namesake of Sugar Plum Fine Jewelry. She believes jewelry is more than just metal and stones - it's a feeling, a tangible snapshot of a moment in time, a celebration, an heirloom. Katelynne is committed to helping everyone feel beautiful and celebrated through carefully curated selections of fine jewelry, as well as her KE Designs line of distinctive, one of a kind pieces, and her personal work with clients to create Custom Legacy Designs.


  • ★★★★★
    I don’t know where to even begin. Kate is fantastic. Whole heartily a wonderful person but an even better jeweler. She custom made my engagement ring and wedding band for my surprise wedding in Texas in 3 short months. My husband and her communicated back and forth down to the millimeter of how he wanted it to look and it is breathtaking! Fit perfectly. No flaws. Gorgeous work of art! Kate thank you again for being an incredible person to work with and get to know!! I’m sorry this review is long overdue. We are so overjoyed with my rings! Thank you again!
  • ★★★★★
    Kate and all the girls at Sugar Plum (oh and Jason too) are incredible! Not only do they help you pick out beautiful jewelry pieces for yourself or gifts for others but they remember your name and exactly what you like. The minute you walk in you are greeted with a smile and someone willing to pull pieces for you to look at and try on. Almost always the first piece they pull for me I end up purchasing because they just “get” me. They are a special part of my story as well, my husband purchased my engagement ring and wedding band there. I live out of state and am always asked about my rings and all of my yogo sapphires and I will always always recommend them visiting the store (which is BEAUTIFUL) or shopping online. I am always so excited to see a little purple box under the Christmas tree as well.
  • ★★★★★
    I started following Katelynne Eslick and Sugar Plum Fine Jewelry years ago and then started my Sugar Plum collection. I have worked with Kate closely to design custom pieces for my friends that all are gorgeous. My fiance had her design my engagement ring and it is PERFECT. Her attention to detail is impeccable and her creativity is out of this world. Sugar Plum has jewelry for every budget and special occasion. I highly recommend you give Sugar Plum Fine Jewelry a call for your next jewelry purchase!
  • ★★★★★
    I absolutely love everything about not only this store but the owners and staff. The personal touch and care they put in to every interaction, whether it’s for a sale or just a hello, makes this the best jewelry store hands down. I’ll never go anywhere else!
  • ★★★★★
    Sugar Plum Jewelry has always done phenomenal work! I am absolutely in love with my wedding ring and bands! Kate not only does great work, but she is an upstanding citizen. She supports everyone local and continues to be a positive impact to everyone around her. I highly recommend Sugar Plum Jewelry!
  • Bailey T.
  • Sara S.
  • Kati E.
  • Andrea F.
  • Vanesa V.