NEW ARRIVALS

Find your next one-of-a-kind peice of jewelry

CUSTOM LEGACY DESIGN

Read more to learn about creating a custom piece of jewelry with award winning designer Katelynne Eslick

FEATURED COLLECTIONS

  • ENGAGEMENT RINGS

    Our collection features the classic solitaire, diamond halos, natural and lab grown diamonds, fancy colored diamonds and more

    SHOP
  • YOGO & MONTANA SAPPHIRE NECKLACES

    Browse the collection to view the variety of colors available for Montana's most famous gemstone

    shop
  • FASHION DIAMOND RINGS

    Diamonds are forever and for every day wear

    shop

Toi et Moi

You and me.

Me and you.

The Yogo Sapphire Toi et Moi Ring symbolizes two becoming one.

LAST CALL

It's last call for these items.

Which one are you taking home?

Testimonials

  • ★★★★★
    I cannot say enough about my entire experience with Sugar Plum Fine Jewelry! I finally took the leap to upgrade my center stone on my wedding band and Kate made it so easy! She gave great suggestions with clear communication. I had my ring back in no time and hardly could believe my eyes! My ring is absolutely stunning!! So much more than I ever expected. 12/10!
  • ★★★★★
    Excellent customer service: friendly and attentive. You are a cared for person, not just a customer, at Sugar Plum Fine Jewelry. Quality product. Quick shipping. Great prices.
  • ★★★★★
    The whole Sugar Plum crew is so helpful and wonderful to work with. The quality of their product and their expertise is top notch! We will definitely be referring them to everyone we know and are lifelong customers!
  • K Schaaf
  • Tammy Gorski
  • Autumn Gault