Sugar Plum Fine Jewelry is located in the historic Krug Mansion, an expansive 8,800 square foot brick mansion, built between the years of 1903-1907. As you enjoy your shopping experience, you’ll be transported to a bygone era and wrapped in the richness and warmth of this site’s original details.


Katelynne Eslick

Owner, Designer, GIA Diamonds Graduate, GIA Colored Stones Graduate

Katelynne grew up in small-town Montana, and as the daughter and granddaughter of jewelers spent much of her childhood immersed in the world of diamonds and jewelry. She sold her first diamond at her parent's jewelry store at age three, and that passion never stopped.

As a third generation jeweler, she believes that jewelry tells a story, and is meant to be passed down through generations. She keeps this idea at the forefront of each of her Legacy designs, whether the design is utilizing heirloom diamonds and stones, or is a brand-new piece starting its own story. Katelynne's award winning designs are loved for their uniqueness, attention to detail, and matching the wearers style. Katelynne is currently pursuing her Graduate Gemologist degree through GIA. 

In her free time she enjoys her children, reading suspense novels, a good glass of Cabernet Sauvignon, and has finally learned how to keep houseplants alive! 

Jayson Eslick

Owner & Jewelry Repair Specialist 

Jayson was a law enforcement officer for several years before changing career paths and entering the jewelry business alongside his wife, Katelynne, in 2017. Apprenticing under Kate's father, Jamie Sharples (who brings nearly 40 years of experience in jewelry repair), Jayson has become an expert in the art. He specializes in state-of-the-art laser jewelry repair. Jayson enjoys watching football and baseball, traveling, cooking, and a good cold beer. 



Peyton Konieczka

Head of Sales & Permanent Jewelry Specialist

Peyton joined the Sugar Plum Team in 2021 originally to be part time. However she quickly fell in love with the industry and has been working full time since she graduated from Dawson County High School in 2022! She is currently working towards her AJP Degree from GIA. After that, she plans to continue her education with GIA! She is the in house permanent jewelry specialist and head of sales!
In her free time, she enjoys painting, reading, and cuddling with her two cats!